Subtopic Deep Dive

← Scottish History and National Identity

Jacobite Risings
Research Guide

What is Jacobite Risings?

The Jacobite Risings were a series of uprisings from 1689 to 1746 by supporters of the exiled Stuart monarchy against the Hanoverian succession in Britain.

These rebellions, including the major events of 1715 and 1745, involved Scottish clans, military strategies, and figures like Bonnie Prince Charlie. Key battles such as Culloden marked their defeat and led to Highland Clearances. Over 30 papers analyze their ideological, imperial, and cultural dimensions, with foundational works from 1985-2006.

Curated Papers

Key Challenges

Why It Matters

Jacobite Risings reveal clan resistance to the 1707 Union and shaped Scottish national identity through enduring myths of heroism and loss (McLynn, 1985). Geoffrey Plank's analysis links the 1745 rising's suppression to imperial policies, influencing British expansion and Highland pacification (Plank, 2006; 32 citations). Adam Fox shows how English ballads constructed Scottish stereotypes as rebels, impacting cultural memory (Fox, 2016). These studies inform modern debates on nationalism and post-colonial legacies in Scotland.

Key Research Challenges

Fragmented Ideological Sources

Jacobite ideology combined Tory hereditary rights, Catholicism, and clan loyalties, making synthesis difficult (McLynn, 1985; 31 citations). Sources are heterogeneous, with English and Scottish strands diverging. Historians struggle to reconstruct coherent motivations without bias.

Understudied Non-1745 Risings

The 1715 rebellion receives less attention than 1745 despite its proximity to the Union (1715: the great Jacobite Rebellion, 2006; 33 citations). Earlier risings like 1689 lack romantic narratives, limiting archival depth. Comparative analysis across events remains sparse.

Measuring Cultural Memory Impact

Assessing Jacobitism's role in modern Scottish identity involves ballads, landscapes, and myths (Fox, 2016; Bonehill and Daniels, 2017). Quantitative metrics for cultural persistence are absent. Linking military defeat to Enlightenment 'improvement' narratives challenges causal inference (Fielding, 2018).

Essential Papers

1715: the great Jacobite Rebellion

· 2006 · Choice Reviews Online · 33 citations

Lacking the romantic imagery of the 1745 uprising of supporters of Bonnie Prince Charlie, the Jacobite rebellion of 1715 has received far less attention from scholars. Yet the '15, just eight years...

Rebellion and savagery: the Jacobite rising of 1745 and the British Empire

· 2006 · Choice Reviews Online · 32 citations

Introduction PART I. THE RESPONSE TO THE CRISIS Chapter 1. Rebellion: Criminal Prosecution and the Jacobite Soldiers Chapter 2. Savagery: Military Execution and the Inhabitants of the Highlands Cha...

The ideology of Jacobitism on the eve of the rising of 1745—part I

Frank McLynn · 1985 · History of European Ideas · 31 citations

The ideology of Jacobitism is difficult to articulate, since it was composed of many heterogeneous strands. The ideology of English Jacobites was a ‘partial’ view of the world. It embraced the pre-...

Rebellion and Savagery

Geoffrey Plank · 2006 · University of Pennsylvania Press eBooks · 27 citations

Rebellion and Savagery examines the Jacobite Rising of 1745 and its aftermath on an imperial scale. The event marked a turning point in the fortunes of the British Empire by creating a new politica...

Jockey and Jenny: English Broadside Ballads and the Invention of Scottishness

Adam Fox · 2016 · Huntington Library Quarterly · 18 citations

This essay examines the images of Scots portrayed in English broadside ballads of the seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. On the one hand, ballads on political themes most often portrayed t...

Designs on the Landscape: Paul and Thomas Sandby in North Britain

John Bonehill, Stephen Daniels · 2017 · Oxford Art Journal · 14 citations

In 1747, a young Paul Sandby took up the role of chief draughtsman on the Military Survey of North Britain undertaken by the Board of Ordnance. This ambitious mapping project was part of a series o...

Jacobitism in Eighteenth-Century Ireland: A Munster Perspective

David Dickson · 2004 · Éire-Ireland · 10 citations

Jacobitism in Eighteenth-Century Ireland:A Munster Perspective David Dickson (bio) Once upon a time eighteenth-century Ireland seemed simple: it was the story of a new landowning class that had inh...

Reading Guide

Foundational Papers

Start with McLynn (1985) for ideology, then '1715: the great Jacobite Rebellion' (2006; 33 citations) and Plank (2006; 27-32 citations) for events and empire, establishing core military-cultural frameworks.

Recent Advances

Study Fox (2016) on ballads, Bonehill and Daniels (2017) on landscapes, Fielding (2018) on improvement narratives for modern identity links.

Core Methods

Archival synthesis of trials/prosecutions (Plank, 2006), ballad analysis (Fox, 2016), visual cartography (Sandby surveys, Bonehill 2017), comparative regional studies (Dickson, 2004).

How PapersFlow Helps You Research Jacobite Risings

Discover & Search

Research Agent uses searchPapers and citationGraph to map 33-citation hub '1715: the great Jacobite Rebellion' (2006) to connected works like Plank (2006), revealing understudied risings. exaSearch uncovers niche sources on Munster Jacobitism (Dickson, 2004), while findSimilarPapers expands from McLynn (1985) to imperial analyses.

Analyze & Verify

Analysis Agent applies readPaperContent to extract ideological strands from McLynn (1985), then verifyResponse with CoVe checks claims against Plank (2006). runPythonAnalysis with pandas tallies citation networks across 250M+ papers; GRADE grading scores evidence strength for 1745 imperial impacts.

Synthesize & Write

Synthesis Agent detects gaps in 1715 vs. 1745 coverage and flags contradictions in ideology papers, generating exportMermaid timelines of risings. Writing Agent uses latexEditText and latexSyncCitations to draft sections citing Fox (2016), with latexCompile producing polished manuscripts.

Use Cases

"Analyze clan involvement statistics across Jacobite papers using Python."

Research Agent → searchPapers('Jacobite clan involvement') → Analysis Agent → runPythonAnalysis(pandas aggregation of battle data from Plank 2006) → matplotlib clan participation charts.

"Write LaTeX section on 1745 rising ideology with citations."

Synthesis Agent → gap detection (McLynn 1985) → Writing Agent → latexEditText(draft) → latexSyncCitations(30+ papers) → latexCompile(final PDF with Culloden timeline).

"Find code for mapping Jacobite battle sites from papers."

Research Agent → paperExtractUrls('Jacobite mapping') → Code Discovery → paperFindGithubRepo → githubRepoInspect(geo-visualization scripts linked to Sandby surveys, Bonehill 2017).

Automated Workflows

Deep Research workflow scans 50+ papers via citationGraph from Plank (2006), producing structured reports on imperial aftermaths with GRADE scores. DeepScan's 7-step chain verifies McLynn (1985) ideology against Fox (2016) ballads using CoVe checkpoints. Theorizer generates hypotheses on Jacobitism's role in Scottish Enlightenment myths from Kidd (2018).

Try Doxa for Jacobite Risings Research

Frequently Asked Questions

What defines the Jacobite Risings?

Series of uprisings (1689-1746) to restore Stuart monarchy, peaking in 1715 and 1745 battles like Culloden (1715: the great Jacobite Rebellion, 2006).

What methods analyze Jacobite ideology?

Historians reconstruct from Tory rights, clan oaths, and ballads, synthesizing heterogeneous sources (McLynn, 1985; Fox, 2016).

What are key papers on Jacobite Risings?

Top cited: '1715: the great Jacobite Rebellion' (2006, 33 citations), Plank's 'Rebellion and Savagery' (2006, 27-32 citations), McLynn (1985, 31 citations).

What open problems persist?

Quantifying cultural memory transmission, comparing Irish-Scottish Jacobitism (Dickson, 2004), and linking to landscape 'improvement' post-Culloden (Bonehill and Daniels, 2017).